The
richness of events that Sid Richardson Museum (SRM) has helps any intern or
visitor gain knowledge. They’re occasional, so I had to wait to attend as many
as I could and write about the content and benefits they provided.
Docents
The
main insight that I have gotten from my experience at SRM is about docents and guards.
What I have learned changed my mind about them. I have been in many different
museums in Dallas/Fort Worth district as a student and a visitor, and I have also
visited museums on tours, all of which helped me get a sense of the docents’
role. From that, I created my own perceptions of them.
Before
working with docents, I thought they were just museum guides without important knowledge.
They would just choose the art they most liked or know its historical
background and share their ideas and opinions. However, after observing docents
of the SRM during ‘Docent Monday Sessions’ learning and discussing their collection
and other subjects that were important to the museum culture, I realized how
important their role is in helping visitors have a valuable experience.
Although most of them are volunteers and retirement age, they are eager to
learn and know the best way to approach their visitors, including blind and
low-vision visitors. Therefore, with pleasure, I will teach and share my knowledge with the docents at SRM On May 13th, drawing from my thesis, my readings, and my
experiences working with blind and low-vision participants.
The guards at SRM
By visiting different museums in the
past, I have gained personal experience with guards. The guards in some museums
would sternly ask their visitors to stop taking pictures of the work of art.
Guards in some museums would not even smile at you when you look at them. Their
attitudes and how they dress make them look unfriendly.
This is not the
situation at the SRM. Guards at the SRM
are very friendly. They guide the visitors if asked. They open a discussion
about the work of art and share their perceptions or what they have heard the
educational guides explain on past occasions. It seems that the guards have had
some training on how to approach visitors and have some knowledge to answer
questions because SRM has two small galleries, and the guards are able to stand
listening to the docents’ explanations to their tour groups.
Docents Training
Sessions
Docents of the
SRM gather every first Monday of the month, and they have an agenda for that
day. My supervisor is one of the educators at the SRM, and she considers what
the docents ask to learn about and sets up the subject on the calendar to find
someone to discuss it with them. This reminds me of the freedom that Freire asked
to be offered to learners. Engaging the learners in the education system is one
of the principles that I see during these training sessions. Sometimes we have a
guest coming to these sessions to teach the docents (us) about a topic that has
been requested.
For one session,
the guest was Judge David
Jackson Break, who has gun collection. Some of it was inherited from his
great grandfather and the rest of it was his own collection. The session title
was “Firearms of the West”
I learned about all the old types of guns you can see in the SRM
works of art. I enjoyed learning about the differences in size, weight, use,
and way of creating the gun.
Another
session that I attended was “Frontiers, Wilderness and Crisis of American
Identity: Contextualizing Remington’s East” presented by Dr. Todd Kerstetter.
This training session was a lecture-style class, and it was very informative.
Docents were saddened or shocked about what they heard, including me even
though I am familiar with social justice topics since I used it in my thesis as
one of the main sources.
Groups tours (First Grade,
Third Grade, Fifth Grade, TCU, High-school, High-school French students)
By
observing SRM docents on tours, I learned how to put theory into a practice
with what I learned in one of the Museum Seminar courses with Dr. Evans. I remember
learning about different types of visitors, such as the elderly, children,
visitors with dementia, special needs, teens, etc. I remember that, as a class,
we would visit the museum and hear from the educators about the programs for
each group. However, being so close to the experience and learning from practice,
as well as the difficulty that docents face, made a big difference and shows me
how I would approach a group from a practical rather than theoretical
viewpoint.
During a third grade tour, I got great insight. The
docent gave an introduction to the child visitors, and it was so respectful.
Instead of giving them ‘Dos and Don’ts’ as the rules that they needed to
follow, he asked them what they should and shouldn’t do and the kids had the
chance to share what they knew. He sang for them while they walked to the
gallery.
He asked them to
create a story about a work of art and every child shared his/her part. During
the story that the kids were telling, the docents were practicing concepts like
‘point of view concept,’ critical thinking strategy,’ ‘how to tell a story,’ and
‘the scene of the art.’ At the end, the kids had the chance to create their own
bandana and type their symbols on it.
One example of a
difficult situation that I observed was during the visit of a French high
school group, who spoke no English. The docent did not know how to approach
them. She tried the VTS and asked some questions. She also tried to tell story
about the work of art. However, they were not responding. Finally, she decided
to talk about the history of the art to make things go on. She tried several strategies and did not get frustrated
or panic but remained welcoming.
Wild West Wits Event
This event is for the public. It is a Trivia program that
the SRM offers multiple times throughout the year. The rules of the game are: 5
rounds, 10 questions for each round, each question lasts 10 seconds before the
next question is asked, each round is inspired by one of the works of art
that’s in the SRM galleries. The group’s winner receives painting posters from
the collection of the Sid. The groups take this seriously and really enjoy
their time.
In that event, I learned about American history and
culture that I had surprisingly not learned at any (ELC) English language center.
During Wild West Wits Event I had the chance to know about the Great Lakes. I
learned names of indigenous tribes. I thought there was only one but there were
5,270 tribes in the U.S. Each has its own culture. I think this event is amazing for Americans
and non-English speakers due to the fact that it is really informative!
Tea and talk event
Tea and talk is
one of the events at SRM. They have this event the first Wednesday of the
month. Visitors gather around assigned works of art to talk about it and hear its
history. Each Tea and Talk has a different assigned work of art. After
finishing the discussion about the work of art, everyone goes to the classroom
to have some tea, snacks and to mingle, which gives them a chance to enjoy their time with new
people.
During the Tea and Talk event some visitors came late and missed some of our discussion, and because of my experience and my idea of feedback loop application, I asked my supervisor to offer
the visitors some cards and asked them to write down their opinions/perceptions
about the work of art so that people who miss the discussion will be able to read these perceptions on the cards and never
miss a valuable discussion. Visitors can add a little comment or be
descriptive. They also can write a question. After that my supervisor would
collect the cards and we would review them together.
My past (first)
experience during Tea and Talk event was not positive if you remember my
previous post. However, my supervisor
and I decided to try again. This time everyone gave their cards back, but some
of the comments were too short, one word. The other ones were feelings shared
about the work of art. The main difficulty about this experience was reading
the visitors’ handwriting.
Since it worked,
I asked my supervisor to offer a stand that has cards and pencils with a sign
that says, ‘the museums is conducting research for visitors with low-vision.
How would you describe this painting to someone who cannot see it?
Grab a card below to read other visitors’
lists of words describing Frederic Remington’s Boathouse at Ingleneuk. Share your description on a notecard.’ This is a separate program that starts April
15th until May13th. We are doing this on only one work of art to start. I can’t
wait to see how people interact with this new experience. Further, to keep the visitors’ perceptions
saved, I suggested my supervisor also write it in the new SRM booklet.
Observing visitors at the
Sid
I noticed while I was working on the
Brown Gallery that one group (Father, a son, and a daughter) were discussing
only the frames of the works of art, which caused me wonder. They were very excited discussing the kind of
wood used to build the frames and the people who would create such a work and
guessing the date/time it was created. That reminds me of what Falk and Dierking in their book the museum
experience revisited, (2013) said, ‘people would have different goals when
visiting the museum.” I would add, discussing frames of the work of art can be
one more goal for some visitors.
SRM booklet
Observing the museum visitors,
I noticed that they first read the labels and then read the SRM booklet. Even
if they came as a group, they would not talk to each other; instead they would
read that booklet, which made me curious to read the booklet and see what it
had. The booklet guide has a map, Fredric and Russel historical information,
then the works of art with their
history.
Because of my experience working with
blind/low-vision people and also trying to apply what I have done for my
thesis, I suggested to my supervisor that I create a booklet that includes tips
for observations (VTS), neutral
visual description for a blind/low-vision
visitors, thoughts of some of the SRM visitors, and discussion questions. I
chose five works of art of Russel and Remington. I re-organized the works of
art based on themes; ‘Cold’ from the collection by Fredric, and ‘Predicaments’
from the collection by Russel. I am going to ask the docents during my class on
May 13th to discuss it and give their opinions about it. Because of
their experience and their knowledge, they should be able to give good
suggestions on how to improve it. They will also benefit from practicing how to
offer blind/low-vision visitors neutral visual descriptions. In sum,
being at Sid Richardson Museum has enriched my experiences and helped me put my
theory into practice.














I am interested about how your neutral visual descriptions turn out. I haven't really got a chance to learn about the process of designing educational material for audiences with low vision.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great post, Hanan! I learned so much about your experience and observations while reading this. I loved reading about how your views on docents has transformed and it is so cool to see your dissertation research in action. I can't wait to hear the results of the stand that you've put out in the galleries that asks visitors to leave their thoughts on how to describe a work of art to someone who is blind or has low-vision. The SRM booklet with neutral visual descriptions and VTS-like questions and visitor comments is a great contribution to the museum!
ReplyDeleteYou brought up a great point and why I think internships are SO important. We might learn something in class but seeing that idea or concept played out in the real world of the museum is incredibly valuable. And, for me, those sorts of experiences cement that bit of knowledge into my brain more fully than just learning it in the classroom.