Volunteering
Docents: The hidden forces that keep museums running
Something that grabbed
my attention in the internship is the docents’ important role in the Kimbell Museum.
I have always been ignorant of how important their work is to a museum because of
my experience about what their job is about, why they are important to a museum
and how they could get this position. Also, because of the lack of docents’
tours in Saudi Arabia, even when I travel abroad and visit a museum, because we
are tight in time, we just walk around in a self-guided tour where we just read
the objects’ labels, or maybe not.
When I first studied
about museums and museums’ education academically at UNT, I was exposed to this
realm by readings, discussions, and museum visits offered in these courses. This
was done to observe docents tours and curators talking about how they teach docents,
in this sense I had more understanding than I did before. However, the theories
weren’t shaped fully until I had the chance this semester to observe what docents
really go through behind the scenes in the preparation process, and what they do
as the front line at a museum, and in this case at the Kimbell. Through this internship
opportunity, I really built more understanding and appreciation of what they do
and how important they are in this museum ensemble. To me, they are considered vital
players of this collective system, where without their work, museums won’t be
able to function to the maximum. Of course, in this ensemble the curators’, and
educators’ job is very important, but without the docents who are always there
for any activity the museum plan cannot happen or might happen poorly.
An important
reason I assume is that there is not enough money to hire a very big number of docents such as in the Kimbell, and pay them, I
assume it is incredibly expensive for museums without a big budget to do. Another
reason is that the training required to be a docent at a museum takes a very
long time. For example, I asked a docent at the Kimbell about the process and she
answered that it took three years for her to finish the required training. Add to
that commitment and passion. This is really a long time for an unpaid position
for a person who is just building their career, starting with school, or trying
to make a decent living. An intern also talked to me about how she wanted to apply
for a volunteering docent position but the manager of the education department
advised her to choose the internship option which was more convenient for her at
this age, and as a student in higher education. So younger generations might
find it harder to be a full-time docent going through all these years of
training, unless they work at the museum as educators when they acquire the
required qualifications, then they can guide tours and be part of the museum
work as employees, or interns.
Thus, some scholars
consider the docents’ training as adult training that requires Andragogy theories (specialized
curriculum designing for adults (The principles of adult learning theory, 2017)) that they apply in order to reach the most benefits in investing in their docents.
This is because they are the creators of the visitors’ experiences, and who are
able to transfer this experience to a meaningful, educational, and pleasant
experience (DePrizio, 2016;
Empower docents with experience training, 2016; McCray, 2016). From my
observations, I find that the Kimbell follows adult teaching methods in a very
effective way. For example, they have a really great approach in providing
visual knowledge such as videos, presentations, documentation and even a study
room for them to spend time on the materials. They also offer lectures led by
the curator, the education manager, outside scholars, and training with each
education/art staff member for each activity. What I really liked about some of
these trainings is the interactive approach that empowers the docents, demonstrates
their point of view, and then for the museum to consider what they offer.
I also observed
that there is also a consideration of the age of the docents. Wherein there is
always recording for these lectures that can be listened to later, and there is
always a microphone attached to the speakers to help the docents who have hearing
difficulty. Another aspect that I find great is the chance for the docents to
grow and learn by trial and error, where they have a chance to try their
teaching style after a training for a certain exhibition. After that they get
feedback most of the time from the education manager to adjust and meet the
museums’ expectations.
On another note,
I find this particular volunteer work beneficial, important, and fascinating for
the structure of any society in many levels. First, it offers an opportunity for
retired society members to feel as important as they were when they had important
positions in their jobs. This is important for inclusion in the museum of all
members of society to be active and contributing to the museum mechanism. I find
it very important for museums to be the place to connect older and younger
generations through the docents’ participation in activities such as art
activities. For example, at the Kimbell, docents help in art activities with
educators especially in annual big events like spring break, and in regular school
tours. Another benefit is for docents to memorize and learn all the information
needed for the exhibitions’ tours. From my observations by attending many
docent trainings that the Kimbell prepared for them and education staff, I
found the information challenging. It requires a lot of studying, memorizing, and
other skills such as presenting and performing the information in an interesting
way to engage the visitors and make visitors’ experience more effective. Thus,
I think these trainings that the Kimbell offers (and other museums who takes
docents’ training seriously) are very important to the community as a whole not
just the docents, museums, or visitors as individuals. It is an orchestrated work
that requires all these participants, and can’t work without them, and at the
same time, benefits all of them.
At the end, I wish
to see such initiative like this start among museums in Saudi especially since
the country is recently changing drastically and rapidly. This idea started after
a conversation with my father who nowadays complains that there isn’t any
function for retired people like him in the society, so they end up with a feeling
of boredom, and invaluable to the community. However, based on a conversation
with a friend over in Saudi Arabia, I understand that this subject is under study
by the authorities which is exciting to me and I look forward to being part of
its development.
References
DePrizio, J.
(2016). Making the case for transforming training. Journal of Museum
Education, 41(1), 3-9. doi:10.1080/10598650.2015.1126057
Empower
docents with experience training. (2016). Retrieved from https://museumhack.com/empower-docents/
McCray, K. H.
(2016). Gallery educators as adult learners: The active application of adult
learning theory. Journal of Museum Education, 41(1), 10-21.
doi:10.1080/10598650.2015.1126058
The principles
of adult learning theory. (2017). Retrieved from https://online.rutgers.edu/blog/principles-of-adult-learning-theory/
This is a great post, Noura. Thanks for the in-depth look at docents and your observations about this important population while you've been at the Kimbell. Some of the docents at the Kimbell have been volunteering there longer than a lot of people have been working, on staff, at the Kimbell! That says a lot! As such, the relationship is a complicated one between docents and museums. They are an invaluable resource but managing/training such a big group of volunteers is a critical but demanding job. I have had the good fortune of doing some training sessions for docents at the Kimbell and at other museums and one thing that always impresses me about docents is something that you've touched on in your post, Noura: the life-long love of learning that they display. That level of dedication is incredibly inspiring! I love that you want to bring these ideas back to Saudi Arabia.
ReplyDeleteIf you want to read about a really complicated relationship between docents and a museum, read this story from Arizona: https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/arts/nightmare-phoenix-art-museum-amada-cruz-docents-fleeing-donors-drying-up-11231441
Thank you L.E.E! It is really a life long learning process the museum staff put into preparing the docents, that really impresses me in both ways. The docents commitment and the museum's dedication to include such population in the community are really impressing to me. However, it is indeed a complicated relationship where they are needed, and really helpful but sometimes it is also challenging to keep them within the museum's preferences regarding teaching styles and information accuracy. Thank you for sharing the article, cant wait to read it.
Delete